As I had noted previously, there is a page on substack devoted to "Saint Tolkien". It explores various aspects of Tolkien's life and writings. But it also promotes him as a "saint".
The latest installment begins:
The legacy of J.R.R. Tolkien (1892-1973) as one of the founders of modern fantasy literature is well-known. “The Lord of the Rings,” says noted Tolkien scholar Tom Shippey, “is the best-loved work of fiction of the twentieth century.” The fame of his works became even more noticeable with the trilogy of films based on The Lord of the Rings produced by Peter Jackson, bringing Tolkien’s world to a new generation. Since Tolkien’s death in 1973, there have also been several publications of his works, including his Letters, which have made many aware that he was not only a prolific fantasy writer, but a devout Catholic as well. The assertion of this profile, however, is that Tolkien was not only a devout Catholic, but a saint.The author, Kaleb Hammond, seems convince Tolkien is a saint, and optimistic that some day the Church might recognize him as such.
After reading a number of installments, I think Hammond has done an admirable job of examining the very devout Tolkien's faith. He and Holly Ordway in her fine Tolkien's Faith: A Spiritual Biography point to the the importance of faith in his life and works.
Now one could argue that Tolkien did seem to lead a virtuous life, and may well be in Heaven or on his way there, hence he would be a saint. But as for formal recognition by the Church as a saint, I am not convinced. Neither am I with Chesterton.
But I am not a Church official. Nor am I privy to the workings of the Holy Spirit.
As for Hammond, I enjoy his research and observations, and I urge him to continue.
It would be wonderful indeed if some day the Church adds a St. Tolkien - and a St. Chesterton - to the declared celestial rolls.
